SENIOR (2016): Played in a career-high 18 games while starting a career-high 11 games... Totaled 15 shots, including eight on goal... Scored in Monmouth's 3-2 win over Marist (Oct. 29), as David Nigro left it off in the box during the 39th minute
 
JUNIOR (2015): Earned MAAC All-Academic Team honors… Saw action in 13 games, including one start at Marist (Oct. 31)… Tallied a pair of shots on goal in the MAAC Championship Game against Rider (Nov. 9).
SOPHOMORE (2014): Saw action in 17 games, including seven starts… Provided an offensive spark, scoring three goals, including two game winners, and added an assist… Scored his first collegiate goal, blasting a shot from 20 yards out for the game winner against Manhattan (Oct. 8)… Scored the equalizer in a 1-1 draw at Siena (Nov. 1)… Scored the game-winning goal at Saint Peter’s (Nov. 5)… Dished out an assist in the MAAC Championship Quarterfinals against Siena (Nov. 8).
FRESHMAN (2013): Saw action in five games off the bench, including each of the last three games of the regular season.
BEFORE MONMOUTH: Captained Ludlow High School to the Lions’ second-straight 2011 MIAA Division 1 State Cup Championship… Named First Team All-Western Mass, All-Scholastic Team, and Division 1 All-Star Team in 2011… Led the Lions to three-straight Division 1 Western Mass Championships in 2009, 2010 and 2011… Helped Ludlow to the MIAA Division 1 State Cup Finals in 2009.
MCCARTHY'S CAREER STATS:
| YEAR | 
GP | 
GS | 
SH | 
G | 
A | 
PTS | 
| 2013 | 
5 | 
0 | 
1 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
| 2014 | 
17 | 
7 | 
10 | 
3 | 
1 | 
7 | 
| 2015 | 
13 | 
1 | 
6 | 
0 | 
0 | 
0 | 
| 2016 | 
18 | 
11 | 
15 | 
1 | 
0 | 
2 | 
| TOTAL | 
53 | 
19 | 
32 | 
4 | 
1 | 
9 |